The First – And Still The Best – Modern Gay Novel



I’ve just re-read this novel from 1948, which I think is the very first ‘home-grown’ gay novel in the US. Vidal rewrote the book in 1965 with major changes and a revised ending, less melodramatic than the original (murder) although the hero’s “hell-hath-no-fury-like-a-wronged-faggot” action seems equally out-of-character.

The City and the Pillar, like many early novels from writers in the 40s and 50s (and still all too often today), shows clearly the influence of F. Scott Fitzgerald: lean, finely-honed prose with a kind of muscular elegance, which works supremely well for this chronicle of the coming-of-age and the coming-out of a gay high-school senior during WW2 and its aftermath. Jim Willard’s briefly reciprocated love for a fellow student casts a shadow over the next decade of his life as he becomes a sailor, then a tennis-coach (and kept boy) in Hollywood and New York.

Scenes in NY and LA offer early glimpses of the archness that were to characterise the author’s public persona in later life and reach an apotheosis in Myra Breckinridge and Myron, the two-volume high-octane farce which for many readers is at once his best and his worst writing. Many scenes – and many of the characters – could as well belong to New York or Los Angeles of today as to the 1940s. Except for some clunky conversations exploring the ‘Nature Of Homosexuality’ which must have seemed insightful as well as daring in 1948, this is a lot less dated than other gay novels of the era.

The sex scenes are almost as discreet as Mr Forster’s – there’s nothing as lurid or as dazzling as Gore would later concoct for Myra/Myron. But overall The City and the Pillar is not only an outstanding piece of gay fiction (better than many that were to come after Vidal opened the floodgates) but also one of the best novels of its era, different from but as exquisitely readable – still – as the early works of Capote and Carson McCullers.

In later life Gore overdid the bitchiness and bitterness, perhaps disappointed by his failure to make it as a realm presence in US politics, the role he most craved. But his output as novelist, historian and essayist was prodigious. Other writers may have left a bigger footprint (Roth, Mailer, Updike, Irving), but Vidal deserves to admitted to the literary pantheon. He wouldn’t thank me for this, but he is probably, as Somerset Maugham is supposed to have said of himself, “in the very front rank of the second-raters“.

5 thoughts on “The First – And Still The Best – Modern Gay Novel

  1. I have long believed the first homosexual novel to be ‘The Price of Salt’ by Patricia Highsmith. I say homosexual as a simple categorisation. Perhaps it would have been better to have said ‘Lesbian.’ Thanks for this splendid post. Interesting to read but also informative.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. Just Wiki’d Ms Highsmith, Russell. SALT was 1952, STRANGERS ON A TRAIN 1950, so Gore was still first with CITY/PILLAR 1948. Obviously Andre Gide came much earlier and probably isn’t thought of as ‘modern’ compared to Vidal and Mary Renault. MAURICE might be counted if Forster had dared to publish it in his lifetime, although it’s closer to the Gide/Wilde era than to ours. I’ve just ordered FINISTERRE (which I’d forgotten until a friend recalled it) and plan to reread CITY OF NIGHT and Baldwin’s ANOTHER COUNTRY. Any other suggestions/comments welcomed.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s